Is Identity Theft Protection Worth It?
Identity theft protection services promise to watch your personal information, alert you to suspicious activity, and help you recover if your identity is misused. They are often marketed heavily, so it helps to know what they do, what you can do for free, and when a paid service makes sense.
WHAT PAID SERVICES TYPICALLY DO
Most services monitor credit reports, sometimes dark web sources, and sometimes bank or investment accounts. They send alerts when they see a new credit inquiry or account, and many include help with recovery, such as guidance from a case manager and sometimes a reimbursement insurance policy for certain costs.
Monitoring is useful, but it is a warning system, not a shield. It can tell you that something happened after the fact. It can't stop a thief who has your details from applying for credit in your name, although freezing your credit can.
WHAT YOU CAN DO FOR FREE
- Freeze your credit (United States): A credit freeze blocks new credit checks, which stops many fraudulent accounts. Freezes are free at Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion, and you can lift them when you need to apply for credit.
- Check your credit reports: In the US, you can get free weekly reports from the official annual report site. Look for accounts or addresses you don't recognize.
- Turn on bank and card alerts: Most banks offer free transaction alerts. Set them for every payment, so you notice fraud quickly.
- Check whether your email was in a breach: Breach-checking services such as Have I Been Pwned can show where your email appeared in leaked data, so you know which passwords to change.
- Use strong, unique passwords and two-factor authentication: Most account takeovers start with a reused password.
Outside the United States, rules differ. Check your national government's consumer protection site, and ask your bank what fraud protections it offers.
WHEN A PAID SERVICE MAY HELP
A paid service can be worth considering if you have had your identity stolen before, if your information was exposed in a major breach and you want ongoing monitoring, or if you prefer someone to handle the paperwork during recovery. Some people also value the reimbursement insurance, although it usually has limits and exclusions.
QUESTIONS TO ASK BEFORE YOU SIGN UP
- What exactly is monitored, and how quickly are alerts sent?
- Does the service offer the credit freeze and fraud alert options directly, or only through its own process?
- What is the insurance limit, and what costs does it exclude?
- What is the total cost over one year, including any renewal increase?
- How easy is it to cancel, and what happens to your data if you do?
Read independent reviews, and check whether the company has a history of data breaches itself. A service that stores your personal information must protect it well.